Let's take a look at this scene....Crowley has told Dean he needs to pick a side. Basically, are you a wishy washy, human loving demon or are you the full on Knight of Hell, Mark of Cain card carrying member of demon-kind? We next find Dean in a pretty much empty bar, sitting at a piano in a state of self contemplation.
He opens his hand and glances at it, takes the First Blade and makes a slice into his palm. He sits and stares, as his hand heals itself. After a moment the scene is broken by Sam's entrance.
My first thought is, wow, the First Blade really has no effect on him. I mean, we can assume it'll kill him, since Cain said that it's the only thing that can kill him and that he expects Dean to return someday to pay him that honor. But he slices his hand open without a flinch. I don't think, though, this scene is about the Blade or it's effects. Dean is contemplating his humanity or what may be left of it.
He still has some emotion rolling around in there. He fell for the waitress at the previous bar. Although he passes it off as just another skank in just another bar, I think there's more to it than that. When the ex shows up, Dean defends her honor and whips him. Of course the Mark takes over and he almost beats the man to death. But if there wasn't some spark of humanity in him, would he have done so to begin with? He could have just followed the guy somewhere quiet and stuck the Blade in him, if a kill was all he was jonesing for.
Again with Lester. His original intent was just to get the guy to take off. He shouldn't have been hanging around while his wife was getting offed. But Dean sees who the guy really is and it sickens him. He shouldn't care, right? And I think that's exactly what he's asking himself, too. Why am I caring about this douche or what he's done? He may have even still let him go if it hadn't been for the 'freak' comment. Touching a little too close to home there, Dean? As Dean contemplates 'What am I?' Lester comes right out and tells him he's a freak. Insert Blade 'A' into slot 'B'.
Dean still has the desire to serve justice, even as a demon. He is not killing indiscriminately. The security guard at the strip club...not dead. Beat to a bloody pulp, yes, but not dead. The ex-boyfirend, not dead. Beat to a bloody pulp, yes, but not dead. But thanks to Crowley, Dean is questioning who he is and isn't that what Carver said this season was going to be all about? Seeing and being who you really are? Who is Dean? And can he even come to a legitimate answer as long as the Mark is toying with him?
When he watches his hand heal, I think HE thinks 'I AM a freak. I'm a monster...not a human.' He has enjoyed this brief respite without all the guilt he has heaped on himself throughout his life. That's why he ran from Sammy. The feeling of finally, finally, having the weight of all that guilt, all that responsibility (whether of his own making or not), off of him...I can only begin to imagine how freeing that must feel to him. Demon or not. Who would willingly choose to go back under all of that. As much as I love Dean, I personally wouldn't want to pick up that heavy load again, either! Can you blame him? Look at the hardship of his life and all the loss he's suffered. No, as much as his words to Sammy hurt me to my very soul, I can't blame him one bit.
So, I think, Dean is truly trying to accept his his demon side by episode end. To quote Cas, he doesn't think he can be saved, whether Sam 'cures' him or not. I think Dean's thinking is 'You can take the man out of the demon, but can you take the demon out of the man?' Although, the Dean fan in me likes to think that there is a bit of thanks in the look he throws at his brother when those cuffs get slapped on. He has given up on his humanity, but maybe, deep down, he's thankful that Sammy hasn't.

One final note, or question really...When Crowley is telling him about the wife that needs to be killed... Dean says fine and gets up, ready to go and Crowley stops him and says "One more thing..." Scene fades to black. Anyone else wonder what that 'one more thing' was??

No comments:
Post a Comment